With the increase in technological advancement, concepts such as online church, live streaming, and online offering to mention a few have become commonplace. Furthermore, the COVID-19 pandemic, four years ago, forced a massive move of churches to the online space. Although the pandemic has become an historical event of the past, church leaders are still dealing with the outcome of the changes this period catalyzed. Baptism and the Lord’s Supper are two main ordinances among Protestant churches, and for the first time, some church leaders were forced to consider administering the Lord’s Supper online or not observing at all. Since the post-COVID phase, some churches have maintained online Lord’s Supper as a norm for non-physical members. The initiation of virtual Lord’s Supper celebration demands theological reflection so that the church may not lose the purpose of the meal in a bid to be pragmatic. This article argues that except in extremely extenuating circumstances, online communion defeats the very purpose of the meal. The article will briefly describe the concept of the Lord’s Supper, explore the emergence of online worship experiences, underscore the COVID-19 as a catalyst to the acceleration and acceptance of online communion as a common practice and finally critique the practice of administering the Lord’s Supper online.